25 Most Valuable Nascar Trading Cards That Are Worth Money

When it comes to trading cards, not all are created equal. Some are worth tens of thousands — even into the millions of dollars. Some are worthless. Others might be worth $5 or $10, but still, be valuable enough to keep around.

There are a lot of reasons why certain cards are considered so valuable and others are just common. It could be because of who is on the card, how little was produced, if it was released as a limited edition, or even how bad the card itself was. It really depends on what you’re looking for in a card and if you’re willing to pay for it. In this article, we will show you the 25 most valuable Nascar Trading Cards.

Top 25 Most Valuable Nascar Trading Cards: Price List

No.
Nascar Trading Cards
Grade
Price
1
2019 Panini Prizm Noah Gragson Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$99.99
2
1991 Traks Jeff Gordon Rookie Card
SGC AUTHENTIC
$249.99
3
2020 Panini Donruss Racing Hailie Deegan Rookie Card
PSA 10
$299.99
4
2019 Panini Prizm Jimmie Johnson & Alex Bowman Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$119.99
5
2019 Panini Prizm Ross Chastain Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$99.99
6
2017 Panini Donruss William Byron Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$119.99
7
2018 Panini Prime Chase Elliott Sheet Metal Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$99.99
8
2021 Panini Donruss Optic Prizm Ty Gibbs Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$119.99
9
2019 Panini Prizm Chase Briscoe Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$99.99
10
2016 Panini Prizm Chase Elliot Rookie Card
JSA Certified
$140.00
11
2012 Topps Allen & Ginter Richard Petty Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$179.99
12
1993 Legends Sports Richard Petty Memorabilia-Silver Card
PSA 10
$279.99
13
2019 Panini Prime Race Used Tires Holo-Gold Richard Petty Card
BGS Certified
$400.00
14
2021 Panini Donruss Kyle Busch Racing Nascar Card
ACG 9.5
$299.00
15
2002 Choice Rising Star Kyle Busch Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$179.99
16
2019 Panini Prizm Chase Elliott & Bill Elliott Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$149.99
17
2016 Topps First Pitch Kyle Larson Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$199.99
18
2014 Nascar Sprint Cup Series Driver Kyle Larson Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$199.99
19
1996 Dale Earnhardt Nascar Wheels Viper Card
GMA 9
$599.99
20
1994 Press Pass Optima XL Dale Earnhardt Jr. Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$199.99
21
1994 Wheels High Gear Dale Earnhardt Jr. Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$249.99
22
2009 Press Pass Element Ricky Stenhouse Jr. Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$99.99
23
2014 Press Pass Austin Dillon Rookie Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$99.99
24
2017 Donruss Bobby Labonte Nascar Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$49.99
25
1988 MAXX Charlotte Buddy Arrington Racing Card
PSA/DNA Certified
$55.00

1. 2019 Panini Prizm Noah Gragson Rookie Card

1. 2019 Panini Prizm Noah Gragson Rookie Card

Year: 2019

Price: $99.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #34

This is a 2019  PSA/DNA autographed card of Noah Gragson. Noah competes full-time in the NASCAR Xfinity Series driving the No 9 Chevrolet Camaro for JR. He is the 2018 NASCAR Camping World Truck Series Most Popular Driver and also the 2015 NASCAR K&N pro series Rookie of the Year.

2. 1991 Traks Jeff Gordon Rookie Card

2. 1991 Traks Jeff Gordon Rookie Card

Year: 1991

Price: $249.99

Grade: SGC Certified

Card Number: #1

A 1991 SGC authenticated autographed card of  Jeff Gordon. Jeff Gordon is considered to be one of the most influential drivers in NASCAR history. He drove the No.24 Chevrolet for Hendrick Motors in the NASCAR Cup Series. He has a bevy of awards credited to his name including the 1993 Rookie of the Year Winston Cup Series and the 1991 Busch Series Rookie of the Year. He is a NASCAR Hall of Fame inductee.

3. 2020 Panini Donruss Racing Hailie Deegan Rookie Card

3. 2020 Panini Donruss Racing Hailie Deegan Rookie Card

Year: 2020

Price: $299.99

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #16

A 2020 Panini Donruss Rookie card of Hailie Deegan. It’s a PSA gem mint 10 card of superb quality. She competes full-time in the NASCAR Camping World Series and was the Most Popular Driver in 2021.

4. 2019 Panini Prizm Jimmie Johnson & Alex Bowman Card

4. 2019 Panini Prizm Jimmie Johnson & Alex Bowman Card

Year: 2019

Price: $119.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #T1

A 2019 Panini Prizm card of teammates Jimmie Johnson and Alex Bowman. It is an authentic PSA/DNA graded autographed card. These two are teammates for Hendricks Motorsports; a card of the duo is very valuable.

5. 2019 Panini Prizm Ross Chastain Rookie Card

5. 2019 Panini Prizm Ross Chastain Rookie Card

Year: 2019

Price: $99.99

Grade: PSA/DNA AUTO CARD

Card Number: #13

A 2019 Panini Prizm PSA/DNA authentic autographed card of Ross Chastain. He is Nicknamed the watermelon man. He was the 2019 NASCAR Gander Outdoors Truck Series Most Popular Driver

6. 2017 Panini Donruss William Byron Rookie Card

6. 2017 Panini Donruss William Byron Rookie Card

Year: 2017

Price: $119.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #82

A Panini Donruss William Byron card. It is a PSA/DNA graded autographed card.

He is the 2016 NASCAR World Truck Series Rookie of the Year, 2017 NASCAR Xfinity Rookie of the Year including many other awards and achievements.

7. 2018 Panini Prime Chase Elliott Sheet Metal Card

7. 2018 Panini Prime Chase Elliott Sheet Metal Card

Year: 2018

Price: $99.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: 07/50

A 2018 Panini prime chase Elliot sheet metal card. It is a PSA/DNA authenticated autographed card. Chase competes full-time in the NASCAR CUP Series for Hendrick Motorsports and part-time in the NASCAR Camping World Truck Series for Spire Motorsports.  After winning the 2014 NASCAR Nationwide Series, he became the first rookie to win a National Series Championship.

8. 2021 Panini Donruss Optic Prizm Ty Gibbs Rookie Card

8. 2021 Panini Donruss Optic Prizm Ty Gibbs Rookie Card

Year: 2021

Price: $119.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #96

This Ty Gibbs rookie card is a 2021 authentic PSA/DNA autographed trading card. Ty Gibbs competes for full time in the NASCAR Xfinity Series, he was the 2021 ARCA Menards Series Champion. His best finish so far in his NASCAR Xfinity Series career is 13th place

9. 2019 Panini Prizm Chase Briscoe Rookie Card

9. 2019 Panini Prizm Chase Briscoe Rookie Card

Year: 2019

Price: $99.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #36

A 2019 Panini Prizm PSA/DNA authenticated autographed card of Chase Briscoe. He won the 2016 ARCA Racing Series championship, and competes full-time in the NASCAR Cup Series for Stewart- Haas Racing. His best finish is fourth place in 2020 in the NASCAR Xfinity Series and 6th place (2017) in the NASCAR World Truck Series.

10. 2016 Panini Prizm Chase Elliot Rookie Card

10. 2016 Panini Prizm Chase Elliot Rookie Card

Year: 2016

Price: $140.00

Grade: JSA Certified

Card Number: #24

This is a JSA authenticated card of Chase Elliot . It is a 2016 Panini Prizm rookie card, Chase Elliot is a valuable player and so are his NASCAR trading cards.

11. 2012 Topps Allen & Ginter Richard Petty Card

11. 2012 Topps Allen & Ginter Richard Petty Card

Year: 2012

Price: $179.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

A 2012 Topps Allen and Ginter Richard Petty card. It is a PSA/DNA-rated authentic autographed card. Richard Petty, a long-time ambassador of NASCAR, had an impressive racing career.

12. 1993 Legends Sports Richard Petty Memorabilia-Silver Card

12. 1993 Legends Sports Richard Petty Memorabilia-Silver Card

Year: 1993

Price: $279.99

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #54

A 1993 PSA-rated card of Richard Petty, it’s in gem mint 10 condition, a very rare, low population Legend Sport Memorabilia card. Richard Petty is not nicknamed The King for nothing, with his outstanding records, despite the fact that he last raced in 1992 his cards are still in high demand.

13. 2019 Panini Prime Race Used Tires Holo-Gold Richard Petty Card

13. 2019 Panini Prime Race Used Tires Holo-Gold Richard Petty Card

Year: 2019

Price: $400.00

Grade: BGS Certified

Card Number: 10/10

This is a 2019 Panini Prime Race Used Tires Holo-Gold Richard Petty Card. It is a BGS authentic autographed card.

14. 2021 Panini Donruss Kyle Busch Racing Nascar Card

14. 2021 Panini Donruss Kyle Busch Racing Nascar Card

Year: 2021

Price: $299.00

Grade: ACG 9.5

Card Number: 03/25

A 2021 Panini Donruss Kyle Busch racing NASCAR card. It is an ACG 9.5 gem mint graded card.

15. 2002 Choice Rising Star Kyle Busch Rookie Card

15. 2002 Choice Rising Star Kyle Busch Rookie Card

Year: 2002

Price: $179.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

A 2002 NASCAR Choice rising Star Kyle Busch Rookie PSA/DNA authentic autographed trading card. With such lofty career wins, Kylie Busch’s cards are one of the most sought-after NASCAR trading cards. Busch, nicknamed “Wild Thing” because of his driving style, has a series of awards which include the 2015, 2019 NASCAR Cup Series champion, 2008 Xfinity Series champion, and many more.

16. 2019 Panini Prizm Chase Elliott & Bill Elliott

16. 2019 Panini Prizm Chase Elliott & Bill Elliott

Year: 2019

Price: $149.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #7

A 2019 Panini Prizm Bill and Chase Elliott card. It is a PSA/DNA certified autographed card. This father and son duo card is definitely one to have. Bill Elliot, who is the father, is a  NASCAR Hall of Famer.

17. 2016 Topps First Pitch Kyle Larson Card

17. 2016 Topps First Pitch Kyle Larson Card

Year: 2016

Price: $199.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

A 2016 Topps first pitch Kyle Larson card. It is a PSA/DNA COA certified autographed card. In 2015 Kyle threw out the first pitch before Boston Red Sox vs Tampa Bay Ray game, this was done in order to promote a Sprint Cup Series race

18. 2014 Nascar Sprint Cup Series Driver Kyle Larson Rookie Card

18. 2014 Nascar Sprint Cup Series Driver Kyle Larson Rookie Card

Year: 2014

Price: $199.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #33

Here is 2014 Kylie Larson’s rookie card. This card is certainly valuable because it is a PSA/DNA card and it is autographed. Kyle has had an amazing career, among many other achievements and awards , he is the 2021 NASCAR Cup Series Champion and Rookie of the Year, the 2013 NASCAR Nationwide Series Rookie of the Year and the 2014 Cup Series Rookie of the Year.

19. 1996 Dale Earnhardt Nascar Wheels Viper Card

19. 1996 Dale Earnhardt Nascar Wheels Viper Card

Year: 1996

Price: $599.99

Grade: GMA 9

Card Number: #43

This is a GMA graded mint 9 Dale Earnhardt card, it is a Viper autographed card with good quality. Dale, A 2002 Motorsports Hall of Famer, had numerous awards and achievements in the course of his 27-year career after 676 races.

20. 1994 Press Pass Optima XL Dale Earnhardt Jr. Rookie Card

20. 1994 Press Pass Optima XL Dale Earnhardt Jr. Rookie Card

Year: 1994

Price: $199.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #46

A 1994 Press Pass Dale Earnhardt junior PSA/DNA authenticated autographed card. He competes part-time in the NASCAR Xfinity Series driving the No 88 Chevrolet Cameron for JR Motorsports. Dale is a 2022 NASCAR Hall of Famer.

21. 1994 Wheels High Gear Dale Earnhardt Jr. Rookie Card

21. 1994 Wheels High Gear Dale Earnhardt Jr. Rookie Card

Year: 1994

Price: $249.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #183

A 1994 wheels high gear rookie card of Dale Earnhardt Junior. It is a PSA/DNA authentic autographed trading card. Dale Jr is a 15-time winner (2003 – 2017) of the  Cup Series Most Popular Driver. He comes from a family of many professional racers including his father Dale Earnhardt and his grandfather Ralph Earnhardt.

22. 2009 Press Pass Element Ricky Stenhouse Jr. Rookie Card

22. 2009 Press Pass Element Ricky Stenhouse Jr. Rookie Card

Year: 2009

Price: $99.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #99

2009 press pass Ricky Stenhouse Junior trading card. It is a PSA/DNA authenticated card. As the 2010 Nationwide Series Rookie of the Year, two Nationwide series championships, including other achievements and awards, Ricky’s trading cards are valuable and highly sought after. He competes full-time in the NASCAR Cup Series for JTG Daugherty Racing.

23. 2014 Press Pass Austin Dillon Rookie Card

23. 2014 Press Pass Austin Dillon Rookie Card

Year: 2014

Price: $99.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #42

2014 press pass Austin Dillon rookie card, it is a PSA/DNA-rated autographed card. He was the Rookie of the year for four different racing series including the 2008 NASCAR K & N Pro Series East. 2014 Daytona 500 Pole Winner.

24. 2017 Donruss Bobby Labonte Nascar Card

24. 2017 Donruss Bobby Labonte Nascar Card

Year: 2017

Price: $49.99

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: N/A

2017 Donruss Labonte NASCAR card, PSA/DNA certified autographed card. Labonte is the 2000 NASCAR Cup Series champion and the 1991 Busch Series champion. He is a 2020 NASCAR Hall of Famer.

25. 1988 MAXX Charlotte Buddy Arrington Racing Card

25. 1988 MAXX Charlotte Buddy Arrington Racing Card

Year: 1988

Price: $55.00

Grade: PSA/DNA Certified

Card Number: #83

A 1988 Maxx Charlotte Buddy Arrington PSA/DNA certified card, is an authentic autographed card. Over his 25-year racing career, Buddy had his best finish at 7th place in the NASCAR Cup Series awards and was among 103 top tens.

Summary

No matter how you define the term, “valuable” is going to have a special meaning to each individual. However, we have tried to compile the most valuable Nascar trading cards available on the market right now. Although there are always special and rare finds, these 25 trading cards seem to be a sweet spot when attempting to identify the most valuable Nascar trading cards.

Leave a Comment

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Pin