19 Most Valuable Mark McGwire Rookie Cards For Collectors

They say every journey begins with one step. It is true also in sports. Every great player was once a rookie. This article is dedicated to the rookie year of Mark McGwire who is a former professional baseball first baseman. His career spanned from 1986 to 2001. Big Mac, as he was fondly called back in his game days, played for the Oakland Athletics and St Louis Cardinals.

Mark McGwire Rookie Sports Cards are hot. All kinds of Mark McGwire rookie cards used to be valued as collectibles. Nowadays, the most valuable Mark McGwire rookie cards have landed in the hands of collectors. In this article, we have put together a list of 19 Most valuable Mark McGwire Rookie cards.

19 Most Valuable Mark McGwire Rookie Cards: Price List

No.
Mark McGwire Rookie Card
Year
Grade
Price
1
Mark McGwire 1985 Topps USA Rookie Card
1985
BGS 9.5
$3,999.99
2
Donruss Mark McGwire Rookie Gem Mint
1987
BGS 9.5
$2,500
3
Huntsville Stars Mark Mcgwire Rookie Rc
1986
PSA 10
$1,125
4
Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire All-Star Rookie
1988
PSA 10
$999
5
Fleer Update Glossy Mark McGwire Rookie
1987
PSA 10
$1,999
6
Mark McGwire Topps Brooklyn Collection Rookie Card
2014
PSA 10
$999.99
7
Topps High Tek Mark McGwire Red Orbit Diffractor
2018
BGS 9.5
$895
8
Pop 8 Mark Mcgwire Rookie Rc Hof
1982
BGS 9.5
$915
9
Mark mcgwire rare baseball card NMT Rookie Card
1989
Ungraded
$500
10
Mark McGwire Topps Baseball Rookie Card
1984
Ungraded
$649.99
11
Donruss Mark Mcgwire Error Rookie Card
1990
Ungraded
$120
12
Mark McGwire 2001 UD Pros & Prospects Building Blocks RC
2001
BGS 9.5
$200
13
Mark Mcgwire Chong Modesto A’s Minor League Rookie Rc
1985
PSA 10
$100
14
Score Mark McGwire Rookie Card
1988
PSA 10
$199
15
Mark McGwire 97 Fleer “Team Leader” Insert  Rookie Card
1997
Ungraded
$200
16
Topps All-Star Rookie Cup Mark Mcgwire Black Parallel Image Variation
2021
Ungraded
$100
17
Classic Mark Mcgwire Rc Rookie Green Back
1987
PSA 9
$199
18
Mark Mcgwire Anchorage Glacier Pilots Rookie Card
1982
PSA 8
$115
19
Mark McGwire 1987 Topps Rookie Card
1987
PSA 10
$575.47

1. Mark McGwire 1985 Topps USA Rookie Card

1. Mark McGwire 1985 Topps USA Rookie Card

Year: 1985

Price: $500

Grade: BGS 8.5

Card Number: #401

This rookie card was made in 1985. It is graded by Beckett Grading Services at 8.5. In 1984 McGwire was drafted into the major league by the Oakland Athletics and he debuted in the major leagues in 1986 with 3 homeruns, 9 runs batted in 18 games. Hence, in 1985 when this card was made, McGwire was playing with the Athletics.

 

2. Donruss Mark McGwire Rookie Gem Mint

2. Donruss Mark McGwire Rookie Gem Mint

Year: 1987

Price: $2,500

Grade: BGS 9.5

Card Number: #46

This card was made to celebrate the memory of McGwire’s rookie year. It features him wearing the Athletics baseball cap and jersey. He holds his bat in the swinging stance. He could have been in a real game or have been posing for the camera. At any rate, this was 1987 when he was maintaining his rookie status, delivering home run hits. He delivered 33 home runs and secured a spot for himself on the American League All-star Team. Beckett Grading Services graded this card at 9.5.

 

3. Huntsville Stars Mark McGwire Rookie RC

3. Huntsville Stars Mark McGwire Rookie RC

Year: 1986

Price: $1,125

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #33

This is a Huntsville Stars rookie card for Mark McGwire. It shows him in a real game in 1986, the year after he retained his rookie status. McGwire played 18 games this year. His success as a rookie was largely influenced by the three years he spent at the USC and on the 1984 US Olympic team. So by his rookie year it was as though McGwire was born ready for the games. This card is one of the most valuable on this list. It was graded by PSA at a full 10.

 

4. Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire All-Star Rookie

4. Topps Tiffany Mark McGwire All-Star Rookie

Year: 1988

Price: $999

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #580

McGwire is seen posing for a picture in this rookie card made by Topps in 1988. He is wearing his Oakland Athletics jersey and holding a bat. He is quite young here as well. In 1988 he was making all-star appearances. He made 32 home runs this year making him the first major leaguer to hit 30+ home runs in his first four full seasons as he continued to bring hits until 1989 and 1990. This rookie card is graded PSA 10.

 

5. Fleer Update Glossy Mark McGwire

5. Fleer Update Glossy Mark McGwire

Year: 1987

Price: $1,999

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #U-76

This rookie card was made by Fleer. The Fleer company started making sports cards in 1923 with baseball cards. By 2005 the company had been acquired by Upper Deck company. This card here shows McGwire in his elements.

From the looks of it, he must have been posing for the camera in this picture. He is seen holding his bat wearing his Oakland Athletics uniform and cap. Behind him are the bleachers where spectators would soon be watching him do magic with his bat. This card was graded PSA 10 and signed by McGwire, making it even more valuable.

 

6. Mark McGwire Topps Brooklyn Collection Bowman

6. Mark McGwire Topps Brooklyn Collection Bowman

Year: 2014

Price: $999.99

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #BC 1

Topps made this card in 2014, bringing back the memory of McGwire’s rookie year. It shows him holding a bat and wearing the uniform of the St Louis Cardinals. He looks much older here as well. McGwire was traded to the Cardinals in 1997 where he finished ninth in home runs even though he played just two-thirds in the league. He played in 51 games with the Cardinals that year compiling a .253 batting average, 24 home runs, and 42 RBIs. This rookie card is signed, and graded 10 by PSA.

 

7. Topps High Tek Mark McGwire Red Orbit Diffractor

7. Topps High Tek Mark McGwire Red Orbit Diffractor

Year: 2018

Price: $895

Grade: BGS 9.5

Card Number: #9

This Topps card was made in 2018. It is graded 9.5 by Beckett Grading Services. It comes with a signature from McGwire himself and has an old picture of him on it. He is wearing a St Louis Cardinals uniform in this picture. He has just swung his bat at a ball. It is any of the years between 1997 and 2001. He may have just hit a homerun when this picture was taken.

 

8. Pop 8 Mark Mcgwire Rookie Rc

8. Pop 8 Mark Mcgwire Rookie Rc

Year: 1982

Price: $915

Grade: BGS 9.5

Card Number: #1

This rookie card goes far back to 1982 before the world of baseball got to know about McGwire, long before his rookie year in ’87. Perhaps Anchorage Glacier, the maker of the card, wanted to let us know just how far the athlete had come.

Little is known of McGwire’s time in college baseball but it is clear from his rookie year that he must have been an exceptional player even back then. As earlier noted, he had a stint playing with the 1984 US Olympic team. This card was graded 9.5 by Beckett Grading Services. Rookie cards are about the beginning of a player’s career so we let this date be.

 

9. Mark McGwire Rare Baseball Card NMT Rookie Card

9. Mark McGwire Rare Baseball Card NMT Rookie Card

Year: 1989

Price: $500

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: Not Numbered

This ungraded card was made in 1989. It features McGwire in action. He is in the swing here, maybe a home run. McGwire was one of the players on the team who played a great part in the championship club that defeated the San Francisco Giants in the Earthquake Series, the famous 1989 world series. It was called the earthquake series because it involved two participant cities that lie on both sides of the San Francisco Bay.

 

10. Mark McGwire Topps Baseball Rookie Card

10. Mark McGwire Topps Baseball Rookie Card

Year: 1984

Price: $649.99

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #401

McGwire is seen here on this rookie card with his bat. He definitely posed for the picture as he seemed relaxed and pleasantly gazed at the camera for the shot. This is a 1984 rookie card made by Topps. This is the year he was drafted tenth overall in the 1984 major league baseball draft by the Oakland Athletics. This card is upgraded but considered valuable.

 

11. Donruss Mark McGwire Error Rookie Card

11. Donruss Mark McGwire Error Rookie Card

Year: 1990

Price: $120

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #185

You’d love Donruss when they capture moments on cards. This rookie card has McGwire on it with his bat. The angle, the color palette and everything about this card just brings back the good old days of baseball. McGwire is here about to swing or has just done so. Whatever the case it was 1990, the year he gave the team 39 home runs, the first major leaguer to ever do it three times in a row. The card is ungraded, valued at $120.

 

12. Mark McGwire UD Pros & Prospects Building Blocks RC

12. Mark McGwire UD Pros & Prospects Building Blocks RC

Year: 2001

Price: $200

Grade: BGS 9.5

Card Number: #9

McGwire was the swinger. He is seen on this card swinging and winning. The energy from his rookie years never waned all through his career. This card reminds fans of this truth in 2001 when it was made. He is wearing the St Louis Cardinals uniform here which means it was close to his retirement as a player in 2001. This card is graded 9.5 by BGS.

 

13. Mark McGwire Chong Modesto A’s Minor League Rookie RC

13. Mark McGwire Chong Modesto A's Minor League Rookie RC

Year: 1985

Price: $100

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #17

This rookie card features a retro picture of McGwire here. He is wearing the Oakland Athletics uniform here even though it was 1985 before he joined the team. It could also be a picture from a later time between 1986 and 1997. In 1984 McGwire played with the Los Angeles Team at the summer Olympics. He played Pan American games and international cups as well. This picture could have been taken during any of these games.

 

14. Score Mark McGwire Rookie Card

14. Score Mark McGwire Rookie Card

Year: 1988

Price: $199

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #648

This rookie card was made by Score to remind fans of McGwire’s rookie year. It is named Rookie Sluggers and with him here is Matt Nokes. This card was made in the 1988 season. On July 3 and 4 he hit home runs that helped his team win in the 16th inning of both games. This card was graded 10 by PSA.

 

15. Mark McGwire 97 Fleer “Team Leader” Insert  Rookie Card

15. Mark McGwire 97 Fleer Team Leader Insert  Rookie Card

Year: 1997

Price: $200

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #97

This is a card made by Fleer showing an image of McGwire’s face and of him swinging the bat. It was made in 1997. He was close to retiring in a few years. By July of 1997 he had already stacked up 34 home runs then he was traded from the Oakland Athletics to the st Louis Cardinals. He led the majors with 58 home runs this year. His contract was running out at this time too and there were talks about him playing for the rest of the season and moving on to a new team. But he signed a new contract to stay with the Cardinals instead.

 

16. Topps All-Star Rookie Cup Mark McGwire Black Parallel Image Variation

16. Topps All-Star Rookie Cup Mark McGwire Black Parallel Image Variation

Year: 2021

Price: $100

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #91

McGwire is with the Oakland Athletics here in the picture featured on this card. Topps made this one in 2001. It is ungraded. He experienced a resurgence in his career between 1992 to 1997. He was on fire in those years. For example on April 21, 1997, he became the fourth and final player to hit a home run that went over the roof of the Tiger Stadium in Detroit. It was a shot that was estimated to have traveled 491 feet.

 

17. Classic Mark McGwire RC Rookie Green Back

17. Classic Mark McGwire RC Rookie Green Back

Year: 1987

Price: $199

Grade: PSA 9

Card Number: #37

Classic Travel made this 1987 rookie card with the picture of McGwire on the front. Here he looks like he’s about to swing the bat. This was his rookie year and he was playing for the Athletics. This year he led the AL in home runs and also tied with Andre Dawson, Chicago Cubs right fielder for the major league lead.

 

18. Mark McGwire Anchorage Glacier Pilots Rookie Card

18. Mark McGwire Anchorage Glacier Pilots Rookie Card

Year: 1982

Price: $115

Grade: PSA 8

This beautiful rookie card features a retro picture of Mark McGwire in 1982. Here he wears the Anchorage Glacier Pilots uniform. McGwire played under coach Jim Dietz whom he remembered fondly. It was after freshman year ended that he joined the team in Alaska. This card is graded 8 by PSA.

 

19. Mark McGwire 1987 Topps Rookie Card

19. Mark McGwire 1987 Topps Rookie Card

Year: 1987

Price: $573.47

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #366

Here’s yet another valuable Mark McGwire rookie card that is quite hard to find. It is a Topps card that has been graded 10 by PSA. The card dates back to 1987 when McGwire played for the Oakland Athletics. It was recently sold on eBay for $573.47

 

Final Thoughts

McGwire retired from playing baseball after the 2001 season. His statistics dropped in later years as he tried to avoid injuries. Yet, fans can look back and smile at the joy they felt at being a part of his career, watching him play from game to game, and season to season. Do you have a Mark McGwire rookie card that you believe is valuable? You may want to share the value with the world. ?

Leave a Comment

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Pin