28 Most Valuable 1991 Donruss Baseball Cards In The World

Consider this — that baseball card you have in your attic may be worth a small fortune. In the world of collectibles, baseball cards are among one of the most popular types of collectibles. The reason is simple: they are inexpensive and accessible to most people.

In this article, we are concentrating on trading cards in Baseball, particularly the ones manufactured by Donruss. Although Donruss trading cards are no longer existing or functioning their cards are still worth a good amount of money. We are going to be enlisting 28 of the most valuable Donruss cards from 1991, in no order these are the top 29 on our list today.

28 Most Valuable 1991 Donruss Baseball Cards In The World: Price List

No.
Card
Grade
Price
1
1991 Ken Griffey Jr. Flawless Card
CGC 10
$48,000.00
2
1991 Donruss Original Ken Griffey Jr  Error Card
Ungraded
$1,000.00
3
1991 Donruss Jose Uribe Brand New Card
Ungraded
$1,900.00
4
1991 Frank Thomas Donruss Baseball Card
Ungraded
$1,241.00
5
1991 Rare Vintage Error Nolan Ryan Donruss
Ungraded
$405.00
6
1991 Donruss Baseball Rickey Henderson Card
Ungraded
$699.95
7
1991 Rare Donruss Jose Uribe Giants Error Card
Ungraded
$599.95
8
1991 Donruss Baseball Barry Bonds Card
Ungraded
$499.95
9
1991 Donruss Don Mattingly Error Card
Ungraded
$90.00
10
1991 Donruss Elite Legends Nolan Ryan Rangers Baseball Card
SGC 9
$399.99
11
1991 Donruss baseball Jose Canseco Card
Ungraded
$299.00
12
1991 Donruss Storm Davis Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$304.00
13
1991 Donruss John Farrell Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$92.13
14
1991 Donruss Jeff Robinson Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$254.13
15
1991 Donruss Nolan Ryan Texas Rangers
HGA 9
$249.99
16
1991 Cal Ripken Donruss Baseball Error Card
HGA 8.5
$249.99
17
1991 Donruss Gerald Perry Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$210.00
18
1991 Donruss Ken Griffey Jr. MVP baseball card
Ungraded
$199.95
19
1991 Donruss Sandy Alomar Card
Ungraded
$149.99
20
1991 Donruss Ellis Burks Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$189.00
21
1991 Edgar Martinez Donruss Diamond Kings Card
PSA 10
$174.99
22
1991 Donruss Will Clark No Dot Error Card
Ungraded
$150.00
23
1991 Donruss Elite George Brett Kansas CIty Royals Baseball Card
SGC 8.5
$149.99
24
1991 Sammy Sosa Donruss Card 147 Ultra Rare
Ungraded
$162.44
25
1991 Donruss Ken Howell Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$143.00
26
1991 Donruss Charlie Hayes Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$136.00
27
1991 Donruss Dan Gladden Misprint Error Card
Ungraded
$134.00
28
1991 Mark Langston & Mike Witt Auto Donruss Card
BGS 10
$129.00

1. 1991 Ken Griffey Jr. Flawless Card

1. 1991 Ken Griffey Jr. Flawless Card

Price: $48,000.00

Grade: CGC 10

Card Number: #49

This trading card is worth a whopping $48,000. It features one of the Major League Baseball League players and Hall of Fame Star Ken Griffey, who was nicknamed “Junior” and “the Kid”. Ken is an American retired professional baseball outfielder. He made a mark and left a big shoe that very few can fill, with his record-breaking reports during his time on the field. This Card is worth having by any fan or baseball trading card collector, it is also a graded card, it is very rare to find a Donruss card that is graded.

2. 1991 Donruss Original Ken Griffey Jr Error Card

2. 1991 Donruss Original Ken Griffey Jr Error Card

Price: $1,000.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #77

This is another Donruss Card that features Ken Griffey Jr. Only that this card is ungraded, but it is in a very good condition. It would be perfect for your collection as a collector. It sells for $1,000.00 on eBay.

3. 1991 Donruss Jose Uribe Brand New Card

3. 1991 Donruss Jose Uribe Brand New Card

Price: $1,900.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #453

One advantage Donruss has over some trading cards is that because it is one of the oldest trading card companies it features old players that made our childhood and left footprints in our hearts. This card features Jose Uribe, a Dominican Major League Baseball shortstop from 1984 until 1993. This card is also ungraded, and it sells for: $1,900.00 On eBay.

4. 1991 Frank Thomas Rare Error Back Donruss White Sox Baseball Card

4. 1991 Frank Thomas Rare Error Back Donruss White Sox Baseball Card

Price: $1,241.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #477

This card features “The Big Hurt”; Frank Thomas. He is an American retired experienced baseball first baseman and designated hitter in Major League Baseball (MLB). This card is graded, it is in very good condition and it sells for only: $1,241.00 On eBay.

5. 1991 Rare Vintage Error Nolan Ryan Donruss “Highlights”

5. 1991 Rare Vintage Error Nolan Ryan Donruss “Highlights”

Price: $970.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: BC-15

The Retired Hall of Fame Star Nolan Ryan was featured in the Donruss trading card.

He was nicknamed The Ryan Express, the American former Major League Baseball (MLB) pitcher and sports official. He was (CEO) of the Texas Rangers and an administrative advisor to the Houston Astros. This card is worth having, with only $970.00.

6. 1991 Donruss Baseball Rickey Henderson No Dot Error *Rare*

6. 1991 Donruss Baseball Rickey Henderson No Dot Error Rare

Price: $699.95

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #761

This Donruss card is ungraded, and it is very rare to find. It features the star player Rickey Henderson. He is a one-time experienced baseball left fielder who played his 24 seasons in Major League Baseball (MLB) for nine teams from 1979 to 2003. This card is in excellent condition. It sells for  $699.95 On eBay.

7. 1991 Rare Donruss Jose Uribe Giants Error Card

7. 1991 Rare Donruss Jose Uribe Giants Error Card

Price: $599.95

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #375

This card holds a memory of Jose Uribe who was regarded as a Giant in the Giants’ principal shortstop for eight seasons, encompassing their 1987 National League Western Division championship. This card sells for $599.95 On eBay.

8. 1991 Donruss Baseball Barry Bonds Card

8. 1991 Donruss Baseball Barry Bonds Card

Price: $499.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #762

This Calvin Edwin Ripken Jr. Baseball feature on this Donruss card looks fantastic for any collector’s collection. It features “The Iron Man”, a former baseball shortstop and third baseman who played 21 seasons in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Baltimore Orioles (1981–2001). That’s record-breaking!

9. 1991 Donruss Don Mattingly Error Card

9. 1991 Donruss Don Mattingly Error Card

Price: $405.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #107

“The Hit Man”, Don Mattingly is featured in this Donruss card. an American past skilled baseball first baseman, coach, and recent administrator for the Miami Marlins of Major League Baseball (MLB). This card is in a perfect condition. For only  $405.00 You can get this card on eBay.

10. 1991 Donruss Elite Legends Nolan Ryan Rangers Baseball Card

10. 1991 Donruss Elite Legends Nolan Ryan Rangers Baseball Card

Price: $399.99

Grade: SGC 9

Card Number: #L1

Nolan Ryan is an all-time Star in the baseball world, he is featured on this card produced by Donruss. Over a record 27-year domain that incorporated play in four decades, Ryan pitched for the New York Mets, California Angels, Houston Astros, and Texas Rangers. This is graded 9 by SGC.

11. 1991 Donruss Baseball Jose Canseco Card

11. 1991 Donruss Baseball Jose Canseco Card

Price: $299.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #536

Jose Canseco was featured in this All-time classic card from Donruss. He was nicknamed Parkway Jose, Mr. 40-40, and El Canonero Cubano (The Cuban Cannon). Jose is a Cuban American retired Major League Baseball (MLB) outfielder and designated hitter. This card Is  $299.00 On eBay.

12. 1991 Donruss Storm Davis Misprint Error Card

12. 1991 Donruss Storm Davis Misprint Error Card

Price: $304.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #185

This $304.00 Donruss Error card headlines George Earl “Storm” Davis, a two-time World Series champion and an American past experienced baseball player who pitched in the major leagues from 1982 to 1994. This card is ungraded, and it is in very good condition.

13. 1991 Donruss John Farrell Misprint Error Card

13. 1991 Donruss John Farrell Misprint Error Card

Price: $92.13

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #106

This Standard sized Original Card of Donruss features the Star John Farrell, he is an American retired baseball pitcher, coach, and executive in Major League Baseball (MLB). John during his eight-season playing career, Farrell was a member of the Cleveland Indians, California Angels, and Detroit Tigers. It sells for $92.13 On eBay.

14. 1991 Donruss Jeff Robinson Misprint Error Card

14. 1991 Donruss Jeff Robinson Misprint Error Card

Price: $254.13

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #245

Jeff Robinson was an American right-handed pitcher who spent six seasons from 1987 to 1992 in Major League Baseball (MLB) with the Detroit Tigers (1987–1990), Baltimore Orioles (1991), and Texas Rangers (1992). He was an amazing player; this card sells for $254.13 On eBay.

15. 1991 Donruss Nolan Ryan Texas Rangers

15. 1991 Donruss Nolan Ryan Texas Rangers

Price: $249.99

Grade: HGA 9

Card Number: #89

This Donruss card has been graded 9/10 by the HGA professional grader. It is also a misprinted Baseball Trading card in a mint condition. It sells for $249.99 On eBay.

16. 1991 Cal Ripken Donruss Baseball Error Card

16. 1991 Cal Ripken Donruss Baseball Error Card

Price: $249.99

Grade: HGA

Card Number: #223

This is an HGA graded 9/10 Donruss Error Card is a vintage misprint. It features Cal Ripken in the 1991 season when he played for the Baltimore Orioles team. This card is sold for $249.99 On eBay.

17. 1991 Donruss Gerald Perry Misprint Error Card

17. 1991 Donruss Gerald Perry Misprint Error Card

Price: $210.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #130

Gerald Perry played for the Kansas City Royals In this classic Donruss Misprint Error Card from 1991. The card is ungraded but it is in a very good condition, with only $210.00 you can have this card on eBay.

18. 1991 Donruss Ken Griffey Jr. MVP baseball card

18. 1991 Donruss Ken Griffey Jr. MVP baseball card

Price: $199.95

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #392

As a baseball collector, Ken Griffey’s cards should be one you want to own, not only because of the records he set but also because he was an All-Time National Baseball League Hall of Fame Star. This card is upgraded but it is in a very good condition and it is a must have, well with $199.95 You can have this card.

19. 1991 Donruss Sandy Alomar Card

19. 1991 Donruss Sandy Alomar Card

Price: $149.99

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #51

This card headlines the Puerto Rican former experienced baseball player, coach, and manager from the 1991 season where he played in Major League Baseball as a catcher between 1988 and 2007. This card has not been graded but it is in excellent condition. It sells for $149.99 On eBay.

20. 1991 Donruss Ellis Burks Misprint Error Card

20. 1991 Donruss Ellis Burks Misprint Error Card

Price: $186.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #235

This  $186.00 Card on eBay was produced by Donruss and it stars the  American retired outfielder and established New England Sports Network (NESN) studio critic and part-time color anchorperson. This card is a must-have in your collection, and it would be a great purchase if you are a fan or collector.

21. 1991 Edgar Martinez Signed Autograph Donruss Diamond Kings Card

21. 1991 Edgar Martinez Signed Autograph Donruss Diamond Kings Card

Price: $174.99

Grade: PSA 10

Card Number: #16

Edgar Martinez also known as the “Gar” and “Papi”, is an American former professional baseball player and coach. This card has been graded 10/10 by the PSA professional grader and it sells for $174.99 On eBay.

22. 1991 Donruss Will Clark No Dot Error Card

22. 1991 Donruss Will Clark No Dot Error Card

Price: $150.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #441

This Error card produced by Donruss features Will Clark, an American skilled baseball first baseman who played in Major League Baseball (MLB) from 1986 to 2000. He played for the San Francisco Giants, Texas Rangers, Baltimore Orioles, and St. Louis Cardinals teams. This card is ungraded, and it sells for $150.00

23. 1991 Donruss Elite George Brett Kansas City Royals Baseball Card

23. 1991 Donruss Elite George Brett Kansas City Royals Baseball Card

Price: $149.99

Grade: SGC 8.5

Card Number: #2

This American retired pro baseball player who played 21 seasons, mainly as a third baseman, in Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Kansas City Royals, George Brett. This card is a standard size produced by Donruss, in this card George Brett played for the Kansas City Royals team. This card is in very good condition, and it has been graded 8.5 by SGC. With only  $149.99 you can get this card on eBay.

24. 1991 Sammy Sosa Donruss Card Ultra Rare

24. 1991 Sammy Sosa Donruss Card Ultra Rare

Price: $162.44

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #147

Sosa Sammy was featured playing with the Chicago White Sox team in this Donruss trading card. He was a Dominican-American former baseball right fielder. He played in Major League Baseball (MLB) for 19 seasons, mainly with the Chicago Cubs. This card is ungraded, and it sells for $162.44 on eBay.

25. 1991 Donruss Ken Howell Misprint Error Card

25. 1991 Donruss Ken Howell Misprint Error Card

Price: $143.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #204

This Donruss card is a misprint Error Card, it features Ken Howell who played for the Philadelphia Phillies team during the 1991 Major League set. This card is ungraded, and it is in very good condition. For only you: $143.00 have this card on eBay.

26. 1991 Donruss Charlie Hayes Misprint Error Card

26. 1991 Donruss Charlie Hayes Misprint Error Card

Price: $136.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #278

This Donruss Card is an error misprint card that stars the American past professional baseball third baseman and retired coach for the FCL Phillies. This card is ungraded, and it sells for  $136.00 on eBay. He was a part of the Yankees’ 1996 World Series championship team.

27. 1991 Donruss Dan Gladden Misprint Error Card

27. 1991 Donruss Dan Gladden Misprint Error Card

Price: $134.00

Grade: Ungraded

Card Number: #228

This $134.00 ungraded Donruss card stars the outfielder, Dan Gladden, a past Major League Baseball player and recent radio broadcaster. He was the first left fielder with the Minnesota Twins’ two World Series Championship teams in 1987 and 1991. This is a card any collector should have in their collection.

28. 1991 Mark Langston & Mike Witt Auto Donruss Card

28. 1991 Mark Langston & Mike Witt Auto Donruss Card

Price: $129.00

Grade: BGS 10

Card Number: #BC-1

This card is graded 10/10 by the professional grader Beckett. This card features two players the likes of Mark Langston and Mike Witt who played for the team California Angels in 1991. Mark Langston is an American former Major League Baseball left-handed pitcher. He pitched for the Seattle Mariners, Montreal Expos, California / Anaheim Angels, San Diego Padres, and Cleveland Indians. The other player Mike Witt is also a professional baseball pitcher who played 12 seasons in Major League Baseball between 1981 and 1993.

Last Words

The advantage Donruss cards have over other cards is that it was amongst the very first trading card corporations of all time, alongside Fleer and Topps. It features very old or former Baseball Star players who made the Hall of Fame list. It is still a great investment to collect these cards. The main point is to always have fun collecting and don’t feel pressured by any of this stuff and remember that the key is to “enjoy the hobby.”

Leave a Comment

0 Shares
Tweet
Share
Pin