While the 1989 Fleer set is the first product to add a Rookie Card of Ken Griffey Jr., the set is mostly known for its many possible errors. These errors include cards with holes, blacked-out faces, misprints, and more. As a result, baseball card collectors have been looking to complete this checklist for decades. With that in mind, I’m going to take an in-depth look at the 29 most valuable 1989 Fleer baseball cards.
In 1989, Fleer printed baseball cards in the United States with a simple idea. They created a set of cards that captured the best players in the sport and put them in one large group. Focusing on rookies and veterans alike, they created a set of cards that could be considered one of the greatest ever made.
Table of Contents
29 Most Valuable 1989 Fleer Baseball Cards In The World: Price List
No. |
1989 Fleer Baseball Cards |
Grade |
Price |
1 |
Omar Vizquel Auto Card 1989 Fleer Seattle Mariners |
PSA 8 |
$79.99 |
2 |
1989 Fleer Rookie Baseball Card Ken Griffey Jr. |
PSA 9 |
$899.00 |
3. |
1989 Fleer Randy Johnson Marlboro Rookie Card |
PSA 9 |
$12,500.00 |
4. |
1989 Fleer Mark McGwire World Series |
Ungraded |
$400.00 |
5. |
1989 Fleer John Smoltz Update Rookie Card |
PSA 9 |
$199.99 |
6 |
1989 Fleer Update Rickey Henderson Oakland Card |
PSA 10 |
$121.50 |
7 |
1989 Fleer Update Joey Belle Cleveland Indians |
PSA 10 |
$101.25 |
8 |
John Smoltz Signed 1989 Fleer Card |
Ungraded |
$99.99 |
9 |
1989 Fleer Deion Sanders Rookie Card |
PSA 10 |
$45.00 |
10 |
1989 Fleer Dale Murphy Baseball Card |
PSA 10 |
$100.00 |
11 |
1989 Nolan Ryan Fleer Glossy Astros |
PSA 10 |
$98.00 |
12 |
Bo Jackson Royals Signed 1987 Fleer Rookie Card |
BGS Certified |
$319.00 |
13 |
1989 Fleer Bill Ripken Baseball Card |
BGS 10 |
$12,999.99 |
14 |
1989 Dave Dravecky S.F. Giants Signed Baseball Card |
BGS Certified |
$79.99 |
15 |
1989 Fleer Craig Biggio Glossy Rookie Card |
PSA 10 |
$80.00 |
16 |
1989 Fleer Cecil Fielder Blue Jay Tigers Card |
Ungraded |
$80.00 |
17 |
1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Card Nolan Ryan Rangers |
PSA 10 |
$179.90 |
18 |
Frank Thomas 1992 Fleer Rookie Sensations Card |
Ungraded |
$143.99 |
19 |
1989 Mike Schmidt Fleer Graded Trading Baseball Card |
BGS 9 |
$150.00 |
20 |
1989 Fleer Roberto Alomar Baseball Card |
PSA 10 |
$79.99 |
21 |
Nolan Ryan 1989 Fleer Update Baseball Card |
PSA 7 |
$100.00 |
22 |
1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Card |
PSA 10 |
$119.00 |
23 |
1989 Fleer Baseball’s Exciting Stars Kirby Puckett Signed Card |
– |
$75.00 |
24 |
Don Baylor Oakland Signed 1989 Fleer Baseball Card |
BGS Certified |
$99.99 |
25 |
Gary Sheffield 1989 Fleer Rookie Card |
BGS 10 |
$59.99 |
26 |
Howard Johnson Signed 1989 Fleer Baseball Card NY Mets |
BGS Certified |
$89.99 |
27 |
Rob Dibble Reds 1989 Fleer Signed Card |
BGS Certified |
$99.99 |
28 |
Omar Vizquel 1989 Fleer MLB Seattle Mariners |
PSA/DNA Certified |
$79.99 |
29 |
1989 Fleer Bill Ripken FF Error |
SGC 8.5 |
$80.00 |
1. Omar Vizquel Auto Card 1989 Fleer Seattle Mariners
Price: $79.00
Grade: PSA 8
Card Number: #616
Omar Enrique Vizquel González, nicknamed “Little O”, is a Venezuelan former professional baseball shortstop who made his Major League debut with the Seattle Mariners on April 3, 1989. In his first game batting ninth in the lineup, Vizquel went 0-for-3 while making five assists. Featured here is a rare card worth $79.
2. 1989 Fleer Rookie Baseball Card Ken Griffey Jr.
Price: $899.00
Grade: PSA 9
Card Number: #548
The next baseball card on our list today is this 1989, Fleer Rookie Card, with card number #548, it has been autographed by Ken Griffey Jr. The condition of this card was graded a Mint 9 by PSA while that of the autograph was graded a Gem Mint 10 by PSA/DNA. This card has also been authorized authentic by PSA/DNA and comes in their tamper-proof holder, you can get this card for only $899.00
3. 1989 Fleer Randy Johnson Marlboro Rookie Card
Price: $12,500.00
Grade: PSA 9
Card Number: #381
This is a fleer baseball trading card that features Rand Johnson the professional player/pitcher but this card Is best described as the Epic Hobby Card by the seller on eBay who put it up for $12,500.00 only. This card has been graded with an almost perfect score by PSA 9/10 which makes it more desirable to a collector. It is a misprint standard size card and Bill played for the Marlboro Ad on the Scoreboard team in the Major League (MLB). It is in mint condition.
4. 1989 Fleer Mark McGwire World Series
Price: $400.00
Grade: Ungraded
Card Number: #8
This is a 1989 fleer baseball card with the popular Mark McGwire featured, his face is on the autograph card top. It is a gem mint card, and it has not been graded, it is an original error card produced by the well-known Fleer. It sells for $400.00 on eBay.
5. 1989 Fleer John Smoltz Update Rookie Card
Price: $199.99
Grade: PSA 9
Card Number: #74
This is a 1989 Fleer Rookie Card with card number #74, it has been hand-signed by Ken Griffey Jr himself. The autograph was valued a 10 by Beckett. This card was also graded an NM-MT+ 9 by Beckett. It has been validated originally by Professional Authentication (PSA) and comes encapsulated in their tamper-proof holder.
6. 1989 Fleer Update Rickey Henderson Oakland Card
Price: $121.50
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #U-54
Rickey Henderson is one of the most renowned players in baseball history and his cards are fast selling. This is another 1989 Fleer Card with card number #U-54 that is not autographed. The card was graded a 10/10 by Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) ; it is worthy to be in any collectors collection.
7. 1989 Fleer Update Joey Belle Cleveland Indians
Price: $101.25
Grade: PSA10
Card Number: #U-25
Professional Sports (PSA) Graded this card 10/10 for a reason, it is a special card with the unique feature of the professional player Joey Belle. This card is in a gem mint condition, It is worthy to be In any collection of a sports collector, it sells for $101.25 on eBay.
8. John Smoltz Signed 1989 Fleer Card
Price: $99.99
Grade: Ungraded
Card Number: #602
This is a vintage signature card from 1989 Fleer Rookie Card #602, it has been hand-signed by John Smoltz himself and it has been authorized valid by Beckett Authentication (BAS) with only $99.99 you can get this on eBay. It is in a good condition, and it comes encapsulated in its tamper-proof holder.
9. 1989 Fleer Deion Sanders Rookie Card
Price: $45.00
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #U-53
This (Professional Sports Authentication) (PSA) graded card of Deion Sanders is a one-of-a-kind classic, it is also a Rookie Error card. This 1989 fleer card is a standard size, and it features Deion Sanders in a 1989 game where he played for the Baltimore Orioles. It sells for only $45.00 on eBay.
10. 1989 Fleer Dale Murphy Baseball Card
Price: $100.00
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #596
This is a 1989 Fleer Rookie Card #596 that has been hand-signed by Dale Murphy. This is a Vintage Signature. It has been certified authentic by Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) and this card comes encapsulated in their tamper-proof holder when purchased on eBay for only $100.00
11. 1989 Nolan Ryan Fleer Glossy Astros
Price: $98.00
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #368
This is a Fleer 1989 Nolan Ryan Houston Astros #368 Baseball Card FF ERROR that has been graded by Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) 10. It is a gem mint condition, and it sells for $98.00 on eBay.
12. Bo Jackson Royals Signed 1987 Fleer Rookie Card
Price: $319.99
Grade: BGS Certified
Card Number: #369
This rookie card features the player Bo Jackson, it is an excellent trading card to be owned. This card has been awarded by the PSA professional grader and it is in excellent condition. This card has also been signed by the player Bo Jackson himself and it was manufactured by a company called score where it was produced between Modern (1970-Now however it is a fleer card and it sells for $319.99 on eBay.
13. 1989 Fleer Bill Ripken Baseball Card
Price:$12,999.99
Grade: BGS 10
Card Number: #616A
This is the highest-priced card on our list today 1989 Fleer card with the card number, #616A This card features the professional baseball player Bill Ripken It is an Extremely Rare Error Card. Never before seen error on this card, which makes it perfect for a collector.
This card has been graded 10/10 by BGS, it is a Bowman sized card in PRISTINE condition cards in pristine condition are usually worth a lot of money like this one here. It sells for $12,999.99 on eBay.
14. 1989 Dave Dravecky S.F. Giants Signed Baseball Card
Price: $79.99
Grade: BGS Certified
Card Number: #327
This Professional Sports (PSA) authenticated and autographed card of Dave Dravecky makes this list more interesting because it is a lot of cards and a fleer card. This card is a great addition to any collector’s collection; it is an original/ reprint card. It features Dave in the 1989 season where he played for the Giants, SF Giants, SD Padres, Padres, San Diego Padres, and San Francisco Giants, and the card is in excellent condition.
15. 1989 Fleer Craig Biggio Glossy Rookie Card
Price: $80.00
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #353
This is a 1989 Fleer Rookie Card, #353 that features Craig Biggio and has been graded Professional Grader by Professional Sports (PSA). It has been valued 10/10 It sells for $80.00 on eBay.
16. 1989 Fleer Cecil Fielder Blue Jay Tigers Card
Price: $80.00
Grade: Ungraded
Card Number: #232
This is a (BAS) Beckett Authenticated 1989 fleer card that features the star player Cecil Fielder. It is in a Gem mint condition meaning that it is in excellent condition, almost brand new. Cecil played for the Detroit Tigers, New York Yankees, and Toronto Blue Jays. This card is a great selection for any sports collector. It sells for only $80.00 on eBay.
17. 1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Card Nolan Ryan Rangers
Price: $179.99
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #45
This is a Professionally graded PSA 10 GEM MINT card. It’s a unique card because it features the player Nolan Ryan, who played for the Texas Rangers. This card was produced precisely during the 1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Cards set. It has a standard card size, and it is in excellent condition. With only $179.99 you can have this card.
18. Frank Thomas 1992 Fleer Rookie Sensations Card
Price: $143.99
Grade: Ungraded
Card Number: #1
This card is very rare and hard to find, it is a short print rookie card that features Frank Thomas 1st Baseman / DH for the Chicago White Sox Superstar Power Hitter and Future Hall-Of-Fame HOF. Rumor has it that The card was put into a soft sleeve and a Rookie Card GOLD Top Loader. If you are a Frank Thomas fan or a sports collector, this card is a must-own and it sells for only $143.99 on eBay.
19. 1989 Mike Schmidt Fleer Graded Trading Baseball Card
Price: $150.00
Grade: BGS 9
Card Number: #582
This card features Mike Schmidt in this Beckett Graded 9 ALMANAC SPECIAL EDITION. It is a 1989 FLEER TRADING CARDS special and it is in mint condition. It sells for $150.00 on eBay.
20. 1989 Fleer Roberto Alomar Baseball Card
Price: $79.99
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #299
This Is a 1989 Roberto Alomar Error Card with the card number #299. It is in a nice condition, and it was graded by Professional Sports (PSA) GEM-MT Rare Condition. It sells for $79.99 on eBay.
21. Nolan Ryan 1989 Fleer Update Baseball Card
Price: $79.99
Grade: PSA 7
Card Number: #U-67
Another Nolan Ryan on our list today is a 1989 Fleer Nolan Ryan Fleer card with card number #U-67, it is in an NM-MINT condition. This Card is priced in your favor – it is graded by Professional Sports (PSA). It is only $79.99 on eBay.
22. 1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Card
Price: $119.99
Grade: PSA 10
Card Number: #47
This is a 1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Cards which features the professional player Orel Hershiser. This card has been graded 10 by PSA and it is in great condition. Oriel played for the Los Angeles Dodgers during the 1989 Baseball Cards Magazine Repli-Cards set and this card was produced in the United States by fleer. With its grade and features, I believe this care is worth its price.
23. 1989 Fleer Baseball’s Exciting Stars Kirby Puckett Signed Card
Price: $75.00
Card Number: #34
This 1989 Fleer Baseball’s Exciting Stars features the professional player Kirby Puckett in this 1989 set. Only 44 of the cards were produced by fleer and it is 34/44. It is not graded yet but it would be with more if it is. It sells for $75.00 on eBay
24. Don Baylor Oakland Signed 1989 Fleer Baseball Card
Price: $99.99
Grade: BGS Certified
Card Number: #1
This is a Don Baylor Autographed 1989 Fleer Baseball Card; it is card number #1 it is Autographed in Black Sharpie and its Condition: Collectible-Like New. This card’s signature has been authenticated and Encapsulated by the Experts at Becket Authentication Services (BAS). However, it is not graded yet, this card is a rare one and it’s standard-sized.
25. Gary Sheffield 1989 Fleer Rookie Card
Price: $59.99
Grade: BGS 10
Card Number: #196
This is a Gary Sheffield rookie (Milwaukee brewers-of/3b goat hof) 1989 fleer “standing with the bat on shoulder pose” rookie card with card number #196 which is graded BCCG10 by Beckett grading services. It has a thickness of 20pt, and it was featured during the MLB World Series.
26. Howard Johnson Signed 1989 Fleer Baseball Card NY Mets
Price: $89.99
Grade: BGS Certified
Card Number: #39
This is a Howard Johnson’s Autographed 1989 Fleer Baseball Card #39 featuring ‘Ho-Jo’ Nickname Inscription, it is Autographed in Blue Sharpie and its Condition: Collectible-Like New. This card’s signature has been verified by the experts at Beckett Authentication Services (BAS).
27. Rob Dibble Reds 1989 Fleer Signed Card
Price: $99.99
Grade: BGS Certified
Card Number: #160
This is a Cincinnati Reds great Rob Dibble privately autographed 1989 Fleer card #160, it has been authenticated by Beckett Authentication Services (BAS) BAS is the top third-party authenticator and is Ebay’s Pre Certified Authenticator. However, it has not been graded yet.
28. Omar Vizquel 1989 Fleer MLB Seattle Mariners
Price: $79.99
Grade: PSA/DNA Certified
Card Number: #U-62
This is an autographed 1989 Fleer #U-62 rookie card that has been signed by Omar Vizquel. It is perfect for any collector or fan’s collection. This card comes PSA/DNA certified thus ascertaining its genuineness. It is 100% authentic and it sells for $79.99 on eBay.
29. 1989 Fleer Bill Ripken FF Error
Price: $80.00
Grade: SGC 8.5
Card Number: #616
This papered material made card by fleer features Billy Ripken in this 1989 set it is in an excellent condition and it has been graded by Sportscard Guaranty Corporation (SGC) where it was given the grade score of 8.5 and it sells for $80.00 on eBay.
Final Words
That concludes our list of the most valuable 1989 Fleer baseball cards in the world. Yours may sell for significantly more or less than these. These are only a few samples, with some of the best 1989 Fleer baseball cards that exist. If you are fortunate enough to own one of these, you will have a great conversation piece for your card collection.
